Empires of the Sun
By LAUREN SCHUKER BLUM, MATTHEW DOLAN and CANDACE JACKSON
Sillicon Valley execs flock to Lake Tahoe, New Yorkers head south to Miami in droves, and Harbor Country, Mich., becomes the Hamptons of the Midwest. A look into why these three communities are seeing a second-home boom. Photo: Fortune International.
New Yorkers Invade Miami
After a series of sluggish years, Miami’s luxury condo market is reviving, thanks in part to help from an unexpected source: New Yorkers.
Where They’re Buying
Single-Tooth Productions/Getty ImagesThe lakefront towns in and around New Buffalo, Mich., are the preferred destination for second home buyers in Chicago. Last year, 25 beachfront properties sold, five times the amount in an average year, brokers say.
Although buyers from Latin America and Europe have been lauded for helping to revive the city’s property prices, developers and real-estate agents now say it’s a new crop of Americans, mostly second-home buyers from New York, that has pushed luxury prices in Miami to a new level—and stirred a buying frenzy.
“A lot of them are buying now because Miami has really changed over the last couple of years, with a ton of New York restaurants and hotels opening up, with new development, and that has really made New Yorkers more comfortable with purchasing,” says Vanessa Grout, chief executive of Douglas Elliman’s Florida brokerage. She estimates that about 60% of her firm’s luxury buyers are from New York, about double the percentage of a year ago. Edgardo Defortuna, president and founder of Fortune International, a Miami development firm, says New Yorkers now make up about 25% of all luxury buyers, compared with around 10% a year ago.
At Faena House, a condominium development with 10½-foot-tall ceilings and wraparound terraces, an 18,253-square-foot five-bedroom penthouse was just listed for $50 million. Over 25% of the project’s 47 units are already under contract; 80% of those buyers are New Yorkers. “Miami Beach has never before seen prices like these, but New Yorkers have,” says Oren Alexander of Douglas Elliman, who is handling sales for Faena House.
New Yorkers have long targeted Miami, but brokers say today’s buyers aren’t snowbirds looking for a place to retire, but often younger people who partied in Miami Beach in their 20s and now want a vacation home for their families.
When visiting family in Miami over a long weekend last February, Andrea Van Tuin, 41, and her husband decided on a whim to look at possible vacation homes. Two days later, they signed a contract for a 2,000-square-foot three-bedroom unit at Paramount Bay, a condo building with floor-to-ceiling windows and water views that, at the time, was still under construction. “We stepped into the model unit and just fell instantly in love with the views—it was a total impulse buy,” says Ms. Van Tuin, an interior designer who splits her time between Miami and New Rochelle, N.Y., after living for many years in Manhattan.
And now that the stock market has recovered, titans of Wall Street are buying again. Financier Randy Frankel, who is a part-owner of the Tampa Bay Rays, splits his time between several homes including ones in Miami and New York. He owns a three-bedroom penthouse at the W South Beach and just signed a $6.4 million contract for a 3,500-square-foot five-bedroom penthouse at One Ocean, an eight-story luxury condo development being built by billionaire developer Jorge Pérez in Miami Beach’s South-of-Fifth neighborhood. “When I’m at the pool at the W, there are so many New Yorkers around it feels like there’s a hedge-fund conference going on,” says Mr. Frankel. “It’s like the Who’s Who of Wall Street.”
The new presence, brokers say, is having a radical effect on the high-end market, which until recently had been struggling owing to the global financial crisis and an overabundance of inventory. The average cost of a luxury condo in Miami increased by 32.6% in the fourth quarter of 2012 compared with the previous year, according to real-estate appraiser Jonathan Miller.
At the Residences at the St. Regis Bal Harbour, which opened in 2006 with condos priced from $2 million to $11 million, sales slowed with the economy. “Sales were completely stalled there until December,” says Bryan Sereny, a Miami broker who has sold several apartments there. Jim Cohen, vice president of sales for the St. Regis Bal Harbour, says activity began picking up in 2011 and has continued to increase, with 77 units selling in 2012 and 38 units selling in the first three months of 2013. Meanwhile, pricing on some units has increased by as much as 30%.
In January, hedge-fund manager Ken Griffin paid $27 million for a 7,100-square-foot condo in the Setai on Miami Beach—the highest price ever paid for a condo in Southeast Florida. That record was broken a little over a month later when a pair of penthouses at Ian Schrager’s new condo project, the Residences at the Miami Beach Edition, went into contract together for $34 million. People familiar with the latter transaction say that the buyer of those penthouses, also an American, edged out Cantor Fitzgerald Chief Executive Howard Lutnick in the sale by making a quick all-cash offer. Mr. Lutnick declined to comment.
“The market in Miami Beach is just out of control,” says Ian Bruce Eichner, the prominent New York-based real-estate developer, who has recently listed his own penthouse at his Miami Beach building, the Continuum, for $39 million. “Ten years ago, if you said a penthouse on Miami Beach would sell for $10 million, people would tell you that you were out of your mind.”
Mr. Schrager, who will unveil the Edition next year, says that seven weeks after opening the sales office in January, he sold out more than half of the project’s 26 units—mostly to domestic buyers, for an average of more than $3,000 a foot. “It was a real risk to open with prices that were 200% higher than the market,” says Mr. Schrager.
The Hamptons of the Midwest
Straight across Lake Michigan from the Chicago Loop is a ribbon of tucked-away beach towns. On the Michigan side, this region is called Harbor Country. Elsewhere, it’s known as the “Hamptons of the Midwest.”
Now, after a slowdown, Chicago’s luxury buyers are returning to Second City’s longtime second home. Roughly 80% of its vacation properties are owned by residents of the Chicago area, according to real-estate agents, including such high-power figures as the Daley family, Mayor Rahm Emanuel and former Obama adviser David Axelrod.
“There aren’t six degrees of separation here,” says Kim Pruitt with the Harbor Country Chamber of Commerce. “It’s usually less than two, because it seems like everyone came from Chicago.”
While the real-estate slump hit both sides of the lake hard—some estimate that lakefront prices fell 25% to 35% during the worst of the recession—luxury buyers began returning to Harbor Country last year. Now brokers say high-end inventory is running low. Last year, 25 beachfront properties sold, five times the amount in an average year, brokers say.
In January and February, seven properties priced above $1 million sold or went into contract, says Dan Coffey, a broker with RE/MAX Harbor Country in Union Pier. One sale—a 6,000-square-foot, six-bedroom, six-full-bathroom, shingle-style beach house on 2 acres, with 200 feet of lakefront—topped $4 million, a level not seen since 2005.
“You can already feel that the market has turned,” says Donna Iwamoto with Coldwell Banker Previews International in New Buffalo, Mich. She and her partner, Karen Strohl, have already sold $25 million in real estate this year.
Harbor Country is considerably more low-key than its Hamptons counterpart. The hub of the region is New Buffalo, an unpretentious beach town 70 miles from the Chicago Loop. An Amtrak line runs on a single track through the center of town, providing connections up to three times a day to Chicago and Detroit.
For regulars, the season gets going when roadside burger place Redamak’s opens March 1, or when visitors start queuing up for ice cream outside Oink’s Dutch Treat. Family traditions thrive, including farmer’s markets, ice-cream socials and a July Fourth children’s bicycle parade.
As with the condos on Chicago’s ritzy Gold Coast, the most prized homes front the lake, and are often set above the shoreline to offer unobstructed views. Many high-end homeowners enjoy their own backyard beaches, or access to a community beach, where on a clear summer evening they can watch a 9 p.m. sunset behind the Chicago skyline.
“If we want to have the culture of the city, we’re just a train ride away,” says Ms. Daniels. “And yet here, you have the quiet and you just feel like you’ve escaped it all.”
Silicon Valley Reboots at Tahoe
The hottest new tech-industry accessory? A house in Tahoe.
Venture capitalist Steven Stull recently paid $11.875 million for a 10,000-square-foot waterfront estate on Lake Tahoe in Incline Village, Nev. David Duffield, co-founder of Workday, paid $25.5 million for another Incline Village estate, according to public records. It was the largest sale on the Sierra Nevada lake since 2008, says listing broker Kerry Donovan.
Brokers in towns surrounding the large freshwater lake, which spans the border of California and Nevada, say sales have picked up dramatically in the last six months, as spillover from the Bay Area’s exuberant housing market has finally reached the area. The Nevada side of the lake has gotten an additional boost since California passed Proposition 30, hiking income taxes on the wealthy and increasing the appeal of owning on the zero-income-tax Nevada side.
Brokers say sales are surging on both sides of the lake. “December was the strongest December we’ve ever seen in the business,” says Susan Lowe, the corporate broker for Chase International, pointing to data that stretch back to 1990. According to the agency, the first quarter of 2013 saw $246.4 million home and condo sales in the area, up more than 70% from the first quarter of 2012.
Jim Telling, a partner at East West Partners, which developed the Village at Northstar, says the company has seen a 72% increase in the number of home sales since 2011. Average prices rose to $869,000 from $531,000, spurred by a large number of $1 million-plus sales.
Kate Wormington, a 17-year Apple veteran who left in 2010 to raise money for an education nonprofit, and her husband, Dan, a current Apple employee, recently snapped up a fully furnished, four-bedroom home that was listed for $2.1 million. The ski-in/ski-out property is at Constellation Residences at Northstar, a Vail-operated ski resort in Truckee, Calif., that was recently overhauled to include boutiques, a skating rink and a Ritz-Carlton. Ms. Wormington, a mother of two, says she liked the area’s friendly vibe as well as its amenities, such as ski valets and a chef-run s’mores bar. “It is amazing to me how many people you run into,” she says, adding that they frequently see friends from the tech world and their hometown of San Carlos on weekends. “It feels like home.”
The change in the area’s fortunes has been swift and dramatic. Though the housing market in the Bay Area has been one of the strongest in the country, Lake Tahoe long struggled to recover from the downturn, with homes frequently sitting on the market for many months and selling well below asking price.
Despite the recent boom, prices still have yet to recover to their predownturn heights. Ms. Lowe says pricing generally dropped about 35% from the peak and is coming back slowly.
Martis Camp, a golf and ski community in Truckee that began construction in 2006, has sold 52 lots and homes since the start of January, says Brian Hull, director of sales, up from 27 at this point last year. Prices for lots range from the mid-$600,000s to $2 million and 108 homes have been completed so far. Mr. Hull says the influx of younger families from the tech industry has resulted in a number of contemporary-style mountain homes with glass-filled architecture.
“Silicon Valley is at the cutting edge of changing the way we live with tech,” he says. “They’re really doing that with interesting homes from a design standpoint.”
Ms. Donovan, a broker with Chase International in Incline Village, the Nevada town where Oracle ORCL -1.19% billionaire Larry Ellison has assembled a 7.6-acre lakefront compound, says Proposition 30 has had a positive impact on sales on the Nevada side. Though several high-profile sales have gone to tech-industry people, she says, the typical buyer is a wealthy baby boomer in finance or other industry from Northern or Southern California looking to relocate. “People are thinking, ‘OK, I’d better just do it now,’ ” she says.
Write to Lauren Schuker Blum at Lauren.Schuker@wsj.com, Matthew Dolan email@example.com and Candace Jackson at firstname.lastname@example.org
Back to Blog